On first viewing of this, I was very disappointed. It really didn't live up tp expectations.
Then I watched the Confidential afterwards, and then re-watched the ep last night. And I was a lot happier.
I also hated the old Docotor storyline thing. It didn't work for me. I get that the Master was lording over the Doctor - keeping him as his helpless pet - but it just didn't work for me. Very old CGI Doctor was cute though

I also wondered what happened to the brother. Why didn't anone in the family mention him? They're supposed to be such a close family, and yet no-one mentioned him??
Add me to the list that thought the sphere were the Daleks! In hindsight though, there's no way the Master would hook up with them - he might be insane, but he's still a TimeLord, so the Daleks are his enemy.
Martha walking away at the end was unexpected (by me). Freema's not left the series, so Martha will be back. It made sense that she wouldn't just up and leave her family though. (I think Rose would have left hers... I think I like MArtha better than Rose!).
Martha meaving left the Doctor all alone again. I felt for him then. He's always alone in the end. And having just lost the Master, and having to deal with being the last Time Lord again, he needed some company.
The Doctor's feelings about the Master - his death etc - was very moving. It really worked that he was desperate for the Master to live, even though he was such a problem for him.
Jack as the Face of Boe! That totally blindsided me! Made me

too! Explains such a lot about the Face of Boe and how he knew about the Master etc. But poor Jack, going to turn into just a face! It also had me confused. Jack is human - so how could Cassandra be the last human, if the Face of Bow was still alive? Surely Jack being human means the Face is human??
I also thought Jack would have chosen the Doctor over Torchwood. Obviously he needed to choose Torchwood, for the show, but I'd have preferred a better reason for him staying behind.
And, as the Doctor kept his hand, and the TARDIS had landed in Torchwood at the end of the last ep there, and Jack had the hand then, and hadn't seen the Doctor for the whole Master thing... I'm wanting to know how Torchwood explains the end of it's last ep without contrdicting Doctor Who

[quoteedited to add. LOVE the touch that they came back AFTER the US president was killed.

[/quote]
I thought this was funny too

Subtle political statement

But as the President was killed by a sphere, surely they should have been around? Or have I missed something?
[quote] I just listened to the Pod cast and the confidential. I assume we'll have a guest companion for the Christmas ep. They were making a big deal. Surely not Billy Piper? That would rock but not just after Martha made her stand. I think the reset of their relationship is great. He's treater her a little bit badly cause he's afraid fo a repeat of Rose. Having Rose come back durring Martha's break {I refuse to beleive she's gone for good, obviously} who screw the Doctor up even more. Wonder who else could it be? Can't wait for Christmas

[/quote]
I don't think it'll be Billie. She's gone for good, surely. They made such a big deal of Rose being gone for good, trapped in the alternate Universe.
Rumours over here say Kylie Minogue is guest starring in the Christmas ep. Maybe she'll be the new 'companion' for Christmas?
I can't wait to find out how the TARDIS gets fixed now the Titanic has hit it

And how come it broke anyway? I thought the TARDIS was supposed to be invincible in that way?
I had to explain to Pip what the Titanic is

How young she is!!!
I wanted Jack to go down his hidden lift thingy into Torchwood too